brentwwodhome_oceano_mattress

The 10 Best Pillow Top Mattresses That Prioritize Comfort

They add extra cushioning for a luxurious sleep experience.
Each product we feature has been independently selected and reviewed by our editorial team. If you make a purchase using the links included, we may earn commission.

Related Content

You don't need to go to a luxury hotel to drift off to sleep in a plush, decadent bed. The best pillow top mattresses use a layer of soft padding to cradle your curves, take stress off your joints, and cushion your spine so that you can get the support you need for a restful night's sleep. This type of bed works especially well for side sleepers, whose hips and shoulders tend to dig into the mattress. Usually this level of comfort comes with a hefty price tag, but you can find quality pillow top mattresses at a variety of price points.

While most sleepers will benefit from the cozy comfort of a pillow top mattress, it's important to choose the right one for you. The amount of mattress brands out there can make the process seem daunting, so the team at Mattress Advisor applied their expert 14-point testing methodology to over 150 mattresses to help streamline your search. Together, we selected the top 10 pillow top mattresses based on factors like pressure relief, cooling, and cost.

Our pillow top mattress recommendations

What is a pillow top mattress?

What is a pillow top mattress?A pillow top mattress can be made out of a variety of materials, but is defined by its ultra-cushioning top layer. The pillow top is sewn into the mattress, and is typically between 2 to 4 inches thick, adding some extra height to the bed. The soft surface of a pillow top provides superior pressure relief and keeps your spine in its natural alignment by contouring around the hips, shoulders, knees, and other high-stress areas. The plush cover allows these tender points to gently sink into the bed, reducing strain.

Pillow top vs. euro top

A pillow top is an extra layer of padding that's sewn into the surface of the mattress. A euro top is a type of pillow top with one key difference: It's sewn flush, which means it has a more polished look and feel. Euro top mattresses are considered to be "top of the line" due to their dense and durable materials, which provide superior edge support to prevent sagging.

The benefits of a pillow top mattress

Plush feel

Pillow top beds are known for their incredibly plush comfort level. They provide a cushioning surface that makes you feel like you're gently floating on a cloud as you sleep. 

Pain relief

The added comfort layer on a pillow top mattress cradles your pressure points by allowing them to gently sink into the mattress, reducing your chances of waking up with morning aches and pains. It's a great choice for sleepers with orthopedic issues who could benefit from a bed with extra padding, or side sleepers looking for more joint relief around the hips and shoulders.

Motion isolation

If you sleep with a pet or partner, you will appreciate the motion isolation a pillow top mattress provides. The top layer absorbs movement so you won't be disturbed by your companion's tossing and turning throughout the night. 

Drawbacks of pillow tops

While pillow top mattresses provide a soft surface to sink into, they sometimes lack the support certain sleepers, like stomach sleepers, need because of the materials' plushness. Sagging can be an issue with this mattress type, which causes the bed to wear down more quickly over time. Choose a pillow top that's built with a strong foundation of coils or a material like latex to bolster the base and create solid edge support.

Types of pillow top mattresses

Pillow tops are almost exclusively found on innerspring or hybrid mattresses because they're designed to soften up beds that feature less comfort layers. 

Innerspring

An innerspring mattress, like the Saatva, is made with a core of spring coils that responds to your movements, gives the bed a bouncy feel, and provides firm support. They're the most breathable mattresses thanks to the ample space between coils, which allows for more airflow. Adding a pillow top to an innerspring bed helps soften the feel of a firm mattress without compromising the support or cooling features that this type of bed offers. 

Hybrid

A hybrid mattress, like the DreamCloud Premier, combines two or more mattress materials in a single bed (most pillow top mattresses fall into this category). They tend to come with a higher price tag because of their complex construction, but hybrids are also highly durable and typically offer a nice balance of support and contouring comfort. 

How to choose the best pillow top mattress

Firmness

The goal of a pillow top is to soften up a firmer mattress and achieve a more balanced, medium-firm feel, so if you prefer a super soft mattress or an extra firm bed, a pillow top isn't the right choice for you. This middle-of-the-road firmness level works well for all sleep positions, but some stomach sleepers may want a bit more support under their midsections.

Temperature

By adding an extra layer of padding, pillow tops can increase the level of heat retention in your mattress. If you're a hot sleeper, you'll want to look for an option that actively promotes cooling with an aerated latex layer, gel-infused foam, or a sturdy coil base. Coils offer greater breathability because they allow more air to flow through the center of the mattress. 

Extras

Before selecting a pillow top mattress, compare the brand's sleep trial and warranty to its competitors' offerings. Sleep trial refers to the length of time you have to test out a mattress before you need to commit, which is typically anywhere between 100 nights to a full year. Because pillow top beds tend to wear down quicker than other mattress types, it's recommended you pick one that comes with at least a 10-year warranty. 

The 10 best pillow top mattresses

Related Items

Mattress Lifestyle Photos
Credit: Saatva

Best Luxury Pillow Top Mattress: Saatva Classic

BUY IT, $1,595 FOR A QUEEN

The Saatva mattress will make you feel like you're checking into a five-star hotel every night. Its quilted euro top comfort layer provides superior contouring and excellent edge support. Plus, this hybrid mattress is also available in multiple firmness levels to suit your preferences. Though the Saatva is a bit pricier than other mattresses on the market, given that the company provides white-glove delivery and setup at no extra cost, so you won't have to lift a finger. And you're sure to enjoy this luxurious bed for many years to come—the Saatva scored a 10 out of 10 in durability from Mattress Advisor testers.

  • Mattress Type: Hybrid (coils and foam)
  • Mattress Advisor Score: 8.7/10
  • Firmness: Soft (3/10), medium-firm (6/10), firm (8/10)
  • Trial Period for Returns: 180 nights
Credit: WinkBeds

Best Pillow Top Mattress for Back Pain: WinkBed

BUY IT, $1,799 FOR A QUEEN

If you're dealing with an aching back but crave a plush pillow top mattress, The WinkBed is for you. Two coil systems and a lumbar support layer keep the spine elevated while the foam pillow top helps absorb extra body heat. Don't believe a pillow top can provide this level of support? Mattress Advisor testers awarded The WinkBed an 8.75 out of 10 in the spine alignment category because of its innovative hybrid construction. The mattress also responds well to movement, so sleepers who like to switch positions during the night stay supported at all times. Unlike many of its competitors, The WinkBed comes with a lifetime warranty.

  • Mattress Type: Hybrid (foam and coils)
  • Mattress Advisor Score: 8.6/10
  • Firmness: Medium-soft (4.5/10), medium-firm (6.5/10), firm (7.5/10), or plus (8/10)
  • Trial Period for Returns: 120 nights
Mattress Lifestyle Photos
Credit: Helix

Best Pillow Top Mattress for Stomach Sleepers: Helix Midnight Luxe

BUY IT, $1,949 FOR A QUEEN

A pillow top may not be a stomach sleeper's first choice when it comes to mattress type, but the Helix Midnight Luxe's supportive design could change that. With a base of over 1,000 pocket coils and three high-density memory foam layers on top, this bed provides more than enough pushback to keep stomach sleepers' spines in alignment. In fact, it earned a 9 out of 10 in Mattress Advisor's spine alignment test for its ability to help sleepers maintain a healthy posture as they snooze. The Luxe also scored well in pressure relief (8.5/10) and responsiveness (8.75/10). 

Another key component for stomach sleepers is cushioning under the chest and shoulders, which the Helix Midnight Luxe has an abundance of thanks to its plush quilted pillow top. If you're worried about overheating, the mattress uses breathable Tencel material to promote airflow (it scored a 9.5 out of 10 in the cooling category). However, couples who move around a lot during the night should be wary of the bed's higher level of motion transfer.

  • Mattress Type: Hybrid (foam and coils)
  • Mattress Advisor Score: 8.9/10
  • Firmness: Medium (5.5.10)
  • Trial Period for Returns: 100 nights
Mattress Lifestyle Photos
Credit: Bear

Best Hybrid Pillow Top Mattress: Bear Hybrid

BUY IT, $1,695 FOR A QUEEN

The Bear Hybrid offers a unique mix of plush softness and expert cooling thanks to its hand-quilted top layer. At its core, the bed features a tier of over 1,300 individually encased coils to provide superb responsiveness and durability. These coils are covered with a layer of gel foam that relieves pressure and keeps you cool. This combination of materials earned the bed a 9.5 out of 10 in Mattress Advisor's spine alignment test. Designed with athletes in mind, Bear mattresses aim to help restore your body as you sleep.

  • Mattress Type: Hybrid (coils and foam)
  • Mattress Advisor Score: 9/10
  • Firmness: Medium-firm (6.3/10)
  • Trial Period for Returns: 100 nights
latex mattresses

Best Pillow Top Mattress for Back Sleepers: Birch by Helix

BUY IT, $1,699 FOR A QUEEN

Made with sustainably sourced wool from New Zealand, the comfort top on the Birch by Helix mattress offers cushy support. A natural Talalay latex layer works to relieve pressure while pocketed coils promote proper spine alignment. Its high scores in both categories (8.5/10 for spine alignment and 8/10 for pressure relief) make it an excellent choice for back sleepers in particular. 

The bed also contains top-of-the-line Greenguard Gold-certified foams, but it comes at a more affordable price point than other organic mattresses. It should be noted that while Birch wool is soft and flexible, it also retains heat, meaning hot sleepers likely need a bed with more cooling features.

  • Mattress Type: Hybrid (coils and latex)
  • Advisor Score: 8.7/10
  • Firmness: Medium (5/10)
  • Trial Period for Returns: 100 nights
Mattress Lifestyle Photos
Credit: Nest

Best Innerspring Pillow Top Mattress: Nest Alexander Signature Hybrid

BUY IT, $1,599 FOR A QUEEN

With the Alexander Signature Hybrid from Nest Bedding, you can enjoy the benefits of a pillow top bed even if you prefer the feel of a traditional innerspring mattress. An upgrade from the brand's flippable foam mattress, the hybrid combines cushioning layers of memory foam and an ultra-responsive row of innerspring coils to provide both bounce and breathability, making it a great bed for sex. Overall, it earned an 8.5 out of 10 for responsiveness in Mattress Advisor's testing lab. 

Nest's Signature Hybrid comes in three firmness levels to suit virtually any sleep position, but fair warning: This mattress isn't the best when it comes to motion isolation, so it may prove too disruptive for couples, especially if one of you tosses and turns. The brand's original motion-absorbing foam model may work better for those who sleep with a partner.

  • Mattress Type: Hybrid (coils and foam)
  • Mattress Advisor Score: 8.2/10
  • Firmness: Soft (3/10), medium (4.5/10), firm (7/10)
  • Trial Period for Returns: 100 nights
Mattress Lifestyle Photos
Credit: Avocado

Best Organic Pillow Top Mattress: Avocado Green

BUY IT, $1,599 FOR A QUEEN

Add an eco-friendly, European-style pillow top to your Avocado Green mattress for a luxuriously plush feel. This pillow top uses organic certified latex foam and provides expert pressure relief with two additional inches of thickness. The materials are nontoxic, naturally breathable, and wick away moisture to keep you cool and comfortable throughout the night. Plus, its high marks in alignment and responsiveness (8/10) from Mattress Advisor make this a great pick for back and combination sleepers. One downside of the Avocado is that it's made-to-order, so it can take a little longer to arrive. But as they say, good things come to those who wait: Avocado is one of the only online mattresses that's 100% organic.

  • Mattress Type: Hybrid (natural latex and coils)
  • Mattress Advisor Score: 8.5/10
  • Firmness: Medium-firm (6/10)
  • Trial Period for Returns: 365 nights
dreamcloud premier
Credit: Dreamcloud

Best Affordable Luxury Pillow Top Mattress: DreamCloud Premier

BUY IT, $1,998 FOR A QUEEN

The DreamCloud Premier builds on the comfort of its original hybrid mattress by adding a euro pillow top. This luxurious layer consists of a silky soft cashmere blend that cushions your curves, allowing you to sink into the mattress just enough for next-level pressure relief (the bed earned high marks in this category, a 9 out of 10, from Mattress Advisor). The Premier's five layers of dense foam and coils provide optimal support for stomach and back sleepers, and its springy microcoil compression system offers superior responsiveness, which is ideal for combination sleepers and those who toss and turn at night. You can buy a queen for under $2,000—a steal given the high-end materials used—plus the bed comes with a lifetime warranty, giving you years to relish in the cushiness of your pillow top.

  • Mattress Type: Hybrid (coils and foam) 
  • Mattress Advisor Score: 9/10
  • Firmness: Medium-firm (6.5/10)
  • Trial Period for Returns: 100 nights
Mattress Lifestyle Photos
Credit: Brentwood

Best Cooling Pillow Top Mattress: Brentwood Home Oceano

BUY IT, $1,499 FOR A QUEEN

Every inch of the Brentwood Home Oceano is designed to beat the heat, starting with its plush pillow top filled with organic wool and cooling gel-infused foam. Made with a combination of innerspring coils, which facilitate airflow throughout the mattress, and open-cell gel memory foam that's both breathable and heat-dissipating, this bed delivers on its promise to cool you down (it scored an 8.5 out of 10 in the category). The Oceano is the top-rated bed in the brand's mattress lineup due to its nine supportive layers (which total 14 inches in height) and nearly 3,000 individual coils. On top of that, Mattress Advisor tells Health that the Oceano is the highest performing eco-friendly mattress ever tested in its sleep lab.

  • Mattress Type: Hybrid (coils and foam)
  • Mattress Advisor Score: 8.5/10
  • Firmness: Medium-soft (4.5/10)
  • Trial Period for Returns: 365 nights
Saatva Latex Hybrid Mattress
Credit: Saatva

Best Pillow Top Mattress for Side Sleepers: Saatva Latex Hybrid

BUY IT, $1,849 FOR A QUEEN

Building on the success of its original mattress, Saatva created the Saatva Latex Hybrid, which offers the benefits of both latex foam and innerspring coils underneath a luxurious hand-tufted euro top. The bed's five-zone Talalay latex layer sits atop a pocketed coil unit that contours to the body and provides pressure-point relief for side sleepers—it earned a 9 out of 10 for pressure relief from the experts at Mattress Advisor. But Saatva's key competitive advantage is its complementary white-glove delivery, which includes setting up your new mattress and disposing of your old one.

  • Mattress Type: Hybrid (coils and latex foam) 
  • Mattress Advisor Score: 8.9/10
  • Firmness: Medium-firm (6/10)-firm 
  • Trial Period for Returns: 180 nights

Mattress Advisor's Review Process

Each mattress on this list was put to the test (literally) in Mattress Advisor's lab, which is located in Raleigh, North Carolina. Bedding experts spent over 1,200 hours evaluating and comparing mattresses using a 14-point testing methodology to find the best pillow top mattresses available online. 

While some of the factors tested are tied directly to performance, like responsiveness, edge support, and pressure relief, others are based around brand operations, such as customer service, shipping policies, and trial period. The Mattress Advisor team combines this proprietary methodology with in-depth interviews and customer experience to arrive at a weighted score out of 10. 

Sign up for our Health Shopping newsletter to get your daily dose of retail therapy with great deals handpicked by our editors — straight to your inbox.