Pfizer and Moderna Are Studying Possible COVID ‘Booster’ Shots—Why a Third Dose May Be Needed
The two COVID-19 vaccines currently in use in the US may be up to 95% effective in preventing infection after two doses, but the pharmaceutical companies behind them aren't stopping there. Pfizer and Moderna both announced this week that a third "booster" dose is being studied.
A statement from Pfizer confirmed that studies involve participants in two age groups (18 to 55 and 65 to 85). Per NBC News, all were volunteers in Pfizer's initial phase 1-2 clinical trial, which began in May 2020. Each participant will be given the booster shot, which will be exactly the same as what they were given last year when they received two doses of the vaccine three weeks apart.
During an interview with NBC News' Lester Holt, Pfizer CEO Albert Bourla said he hopes a third dose of the vaccine will offer better protection against COVID-19 variants by boosting the immune response even higher.
"We believe that the third dose will raise the antibody response 10- to 20- fold," Bourla said.
Moderna has developed a different version of the vaccine designed to target the variant from South Africa. The company's plans are threefold: use variant-specific booster shots, but at a lower dose than the original vaccine; combine the original vaccine with a variant-specific vaccine to create a single, 50-microgram-or-lower shot; and test a third shot of the original vaccine at a lower dosage.
Pfizer also announced plans to begin testing whether a modified version of the vaccine works well against variant B.1.351, which was first detected in South Africa in late December.
The company is looking to see if a booster provides an added benefit against variants, which may be more resistant to the standard two-dose regimen, infectious disease expert Amesh A. Adalja, MD, senior scholar at the Johns Hopkins Center for Health Security in Baltimore, tells Health. The hypothesis, as he explains it, is that a third dose will boost immunity, making the original vaccine more robust against variants, such as B.1.351.
What is a booster shot?
Generally, it's a dose of vaccine following the initial dose or series, which is given to enhance waning immune protection against the targeted disease over time. "The most common example is tetanus, where adequate protection following a tetanus shot is not deemed to be reliable beyond 5-10 years," Charles Bailey, MD, medical director for infection prevention at Providence St. Joseph Hospital and Providence Mission Hospital in Orange County, California, tells Health. "Therefore there is the need for a new tetanus 'booster' following an exposure (e.g., sustaining a dirty wound) that occurs more than 5 years (dirty wound) or 10 years (clean wound) from the previous shot."
However, Dr. Bailey points out that this is different from the situation where repeated doses of a vaccine are required due to changes in the targeted pathogen that render previous doses less effective. "Influenza is the prime example here," he says. "The effectiveness of each year's flu vaccination might well last for a number or years, but minor changes in the genetic make-up of the influenza virus on a yearly basis mandate a new flu vaccine 'cocktail' annually—comprised of several components targeting the three or four most prominent flu strains found to be in current circulation."
Dr. Bailey says it's important to distinguish this practice from what we commonly refer to as a "booster," because it's not driven by waning immunity but by elements of the pathogen targeted by the vaccine.
Why do we need a "booster" if effectiveness of the vaccine is already 95%?
Studies showing COVID-19 vaccine effectiveness only gauged the ability to positively impact severe disease, not how long such protection may last, Dr. Bailey explains. "This will be gleaned from what we experience worldwide in the wake of widespread vaccine use," he adds. "Given the (not unexpected) discovery of variant COVID virus strains that, in some cases, appear to be less fully protected against by some of the current vaccines, the need for future 'booster' doses has been discussed."
Only time will reveal to what extent future additional "booster" doses may be needed and what form that may take. Strategies may vary from one part of the world to another depending on which vaccines were administered and how long protection against a locally circulating COVID-19 strain seems to last," Dr. Bailey explains. "Much will depend on the future course of the pandemic," he says, "but having a variety of vaccines from which to craft our strategy moving forward can only help."