Stethoscopes Can Be Major Germ Hot Spots, Study Finds. Here's How to Protect Yourself
An analysis of this common medical instrument showed significant contaminants, including potentially dangerous staph bacteria.
A visit to the doctor’s office or hospital is supposed to help you get (or stay) healthy. But by their very nature, health-care settings are plagued with one big problem: They’re full of sick people, and sick people are full of germs.
Because of that, infections passed from person to person are a serious concern. And now, a new study suggests one possible way illnesses may be transmitted to unsuspecting patients: According to an analysis of 40 stethoscopes used in a hospital setting, this vital doctor’s tool is commonly loaded with bacteria—including some seriously dangerous strains.
The study, published this week in Infection Control & Hospital Epidemiology, was carried out at the University of Pennsylvania Perelman School of Medicine. Researchers used molecular sequencing to determine the bacterial makeup on the surface of 20 reusable stethoscopes and 20 single-use stethoscopes that were currently being utilized in the hospital’s intensive care unit. They also analyzed 10 unused stethoscopes, to serve as a control group in the study.
What they found was concerning, although not totally surprising, says lead author Ronald Collman, MD, professor of medicine, pulmonary, allergy, and critical care at the university. All 40 of the in-use stethoscopes were “significantly contaminated with a rich and diverse community of bacteria,” according to the study. More than half contained Staphylococcus aureus, a germ that can cause serious and potentially fatal staph infections.
Before you freak out, however, the study doesn’t mean that every stethoscope patients come into contact with will be covered in germs. It all depends on how the instruments are used, Dr. Collman tells Health, and how they’re cleaned between use. (The researchers also could not determine if the bacteria on the stethoscopes was alive or dead—or if the stethoscopes in the study ever made patients ill—so they can’t say whether these devices have transmitted infections to patients.)
The study actually looked at practices for disinfecting stethoscopes between use, and—no surprises here—found that when hospital staff followed a standardized, CDC-recommended approach (using hydrogen peroxide wipes for 60 seconds), the stethoscopes were much cleaner than when they used what the study described as their usual methods, which involved alcohol swabs, bleach wipes, or hydrogen peroxide for different durations.
While none of these methods were able to get the stethoscopes consistently spotless, the standardized cleaning process reached germ-free level about half of the time—compared to just 10% of the time with the other methods.
Dr. Collman says it’s important that people don’t panic about this news, and that it’s no reason to avoid the doctor or the hospital. But it is a good reminder, he says—to both health-care professionals and to patients—that proper disinfecting and infection-control standards are critical, and should be enforced at every facility.
He also points out that when hospital patients have a known infection that could be transmitted to others, it’s common practice for doctors to use single-use stethoscopes that stay in the patient’s room and are thrown out when the patient is discharged. “We know that’s one good way of preventing it from spreading,” he says.
Patients shouldn’t feel shy inquiring about a facility’s policies and their efforts to reduce infection, says Dr. Collman. “Just as you might ask a physician or a nurse if they washed their hands, you also might ask if the stethoscope they’re about to use is clean,” he says. It’s important for patients to be proactive members of their own health-care team, he says, “and those questions are always a reasonable thing to ask."
To get our top stories delivered to your inbox, sign up for the Healthy Living newsletter