Pre-Made Cookie Dough Showdown

7 of 10

Runner-up: Chrysalis Cookie Dough Old Fashioned Molasses

These cookies taste like your wintertime favorites, with a pinch of cloves and a rich molasses flavor. Eat with a scoop of fat-free, organic vanilla ice cream, and you’ve got a delectable—and natural—dessert. ($26 for 36 cookies; doughgirlskitchen.com)

Healthy selling point: Organic flour and cane juice

Total calories: 150; total fat: 5 grams

Next: Best classic chocolate chip