Shoveling Snow? How to Protect Your Back (and Your Heart)
Snow and ice can make driving treacherous, of course, but snowfallespecially the wet, heavy kindcan be dangerous even if you never leave your driveway. Each year, shoveling piles of snow after a storm is believed to cause tens of thousands of back and shoulder injuries in the United States, not to mention several hundred heart attacks.
Overall, more than 70,000 people ended up with a shoveling-related injury bad enough to trigger a doctors visit in 2008, according to the Consumer Products Safety Commission. A quarter of those people visited an emergency room, and about 900 were admitted to a hospital.
The exertion, cold weather, and slippery surfaces snow shovelers face are a dangerous combination, especially if its an activity youre not used to. Snow shoveling "is one of the most high-intensity exercises you can do," says Suzanne Steinbaum, DO, a preventive cardiologist at Lenox Hill Hospital, in New York City. "Youre using all your major muscle groups."
But there are steps you can take to shovel safely and ensure that you survive the winter in one piece.
The number-one injury sustained after a snowstorm is lower back strain, according to Henry Goitz, MD, an orthopedic surgeon at Henry Ford Hospital, in Detroit, and a spokesman for the American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons (AAOS). "Thats when a muscle gets over-tensioned and tightens," he explains. "If it over-tightens, its almost like a spasm and that gets very painful."
Another common back injury incurred during shoveling is a herniated disk, says Victor Khabie, MD, the co-chief of orthopedic surgery at Northern Westchester Hospital, in Mt. Kisco, N.Y. A herniated disk (also known as a slipped disk) is when one of the soft disks between the vertebrae comes out of position and pushes on a nerve.
If your post-shoveling recovery includes back pain that radiates down your leg, its a bad sign. "That may mean you have ruptured or herniated a disk," Dr. Khabie says.
The combination of frigid weather and normally sedentary people going all-out can be a recipe for back injuries. "The shoveling tends to be done by people who are not otherwise in good shape," says Richard Pomerantz, MD, a professor of medicine in cardiology at the University of Rochester Medical Center, in Rochester, N.Y. "Sometimes a potato chip is the heaviest thing theyve lifted for a while."
The snow is not the only danger. Ice lurking underneath snow can potentially cause even worse injuries. Evalina L. Burger, MD, a vice chair and associate professor of orthopedics at the University of Colorado, in Denver, says she has seen no acute injuries from shoveling over the past three years but "horrible injuries from slipping on ice, including bad fractures."
"The worst thing is a fall," she says. "Its not just old people who fall."
Though rare, heart attacks that occur while shoveling snow have a long-standing place in medical loremuch like heart attacks that occur during sex.
In the late 1970s, researchers from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention studied six major snowstorms in Massachusetts (including the record-setting Blizzard of ‘78), and found that heart disease-related deaths rose by 22% in the week following a storm. Men were responsible for the majority of the spike, which "might be explained by snow shoveling," the researchers noted.
The combination of exertion and cold weather are believed to be the cause of shoveling-related heart attacks. "We dont like heart patients doing tons of heavy weight lifting coupled with cold weather," says Dr. Pomerantz, whose home of Rochester averages about 7 feet 8 inches of snow each year.
Theres both an aerobic and weight lifting component to snow shoveling, says Dr. Pomerantz, and the weight lifting portion can raise blood pressure. "Youre increasing the load on the heart very, very quickly when maybe the heart is not used to it," he says. "If you do that in a setting where its cold, your arteries and vessels tend to constrict, so the relative blood supply goes down at a time when youre asking the heart to do a lot more. Demand is high and supply is low and that can be too much sometimes."
Moreover, hormones released during cold weather and exercise can cause plaquesfatty deposits that line artery wallsto rupture, leading to blood clots and heart attacks. "If you have plaque in your arteries, this is a perfect time for them to rupture and lead to a heart attack," Dr. Steinbaum says.
Timing may also be a factor. According to a 1996 study in the American Journal of Cardiology, many people shovel in the early morning, when the risk for heart attacks is higher.
To avoid injury, shovelers should follow a few simple rules:
Stay in shape. People who are in shape year-round have less to worry about when the flakes start falling.
Work up to it. Warm up inside, and incorporate stretches (especially for the hamstrings) as well as core-strengthening exercises such as mini sit-ups, crunches, or working an exercise ball.
Dont try to do it all at once. Shovel small amounts of snow at a time, especially if the snow is heavy and water-laden. "If youre not used to exercising or youve had a back problem in the past, the smart way of approaching this is to do a little bit at a time," says Dr. Khabie. Shovel for 5 or 10 minutes, then go back inside for 10 minutes to do more stretching.
Practice proper technique. The AAOS advises pushing the snow-containing shovel instead of lifting it. But if you do have to lift, "do more of a knee squat, your back arched as if looking to the sky," Dr. Goitz advises. Dont bend from your waist. When disposing of the snow, keep the shovel close to your body and, again, squat with your legs, Dr. Goitz says. Walk over to where youre going to dump the snow, as opposed to leaning over and throwing it. By no means should you rotate or twist your body. "Thats the worst thing you can do for your back in general," says Dr. Burger. "Thats how you herniate disks."
Pick the right tools. Ergonomic shovels "tend to take the stress off the back," Dr. Khabie says. Adds Dr. Burger, "The bent handle gives you a better angle. You dont have to go down so far and you dont have to go all the way back up."
Layer warm clothing. Being underdressed will leave you vulnerable to a painful strain. "You dont want to go out there and really freeze because it will tighten up your muscles," Dr. Khabie says.
Wear snow boots with good traction. "If your feet slip, it throws off your entire balance," Dr. Khabie says. "Find a good, sturdy snow boot thats made to be out in the snow." Consider keeping a set of spikes in your car, Dr. Burger adds. "They take two minutes to put onversus six weeks off from work if you injure yourself."
The cardinal rule is to practice a bit of common sense. As with any exercise, if youre out of shape, have had back injuries in the past, or have a history of heart disease, check with your doctor before tackling that snowdrift. This is wise even if you dont have heart problems but have high blood pressure or diabetes, or are overweightall of which are risk factors for heart disease.
For some people, the safest thing to do might be to outsource the job to a son, daughter, or neighborhood teenager whos looking to earn a little pocket money.