ParaGard (pictured) and Mirena are your two IUD options.(GETTY IMAGES)The new generation of intrauterine devices (IUDs) is one of the best kept secrets in birth control, according to a 2006 University of Rochester Medical Center study of American awareness. Only about 2% of American women use IUDs, but they are so safe, long-lasting, and effective that theyre the most popular form of reversible birth control in the world.
So how to explain Americans continued hesitation to embrace the IUD?
Certainly there are lingering doubts from the days of the Dalkon Shield, an IUD that was pulled off the market in 1974 because it caused bacterial infections. This contributed to Congress's decision to increase the FDA's authority to oversee medical devices. "It was a defective device that should never have been allowed on the market," says Anne Foster-Rosales, MD, chief medical officer for Planned Parenthood Golden Gate and assistant clinical professor at the University of California, San Francisco. "The old device had a string made from a material that allowed bacteria to cling to it and climb into the uterus and create bacterial infections. The strings and materials in modern IUDs are made of totally different materials and are considered extremely safe."
More about birth control
ParaGard and Mirena
The two IUDs currently on the market are ParaGard, a copper IUD that lasts for 12 years and is considered 99.2% effective, and Mirena, which contains a synthetic hormone called levonorgestrel and retains its 99.9% effectiveness rate for five years. (Neither is effective at preventing sexually transmitted diseases, or STDs, just pregnancy.)
While the exact mechanism of action of IUDs is not completely understood, research points to specific reasons for the superior efficacy of ParaGard and Mirena. The copper IUD works primarily as a spermicide. The copper on the IUD reduces sperm motility such that sperm rarely reach the fallopian tube and are unable to fertilize the egg. The levonorgestrel-releasing IUD primarily works by causing cervical mucus to become thicker so that sperm cannot enter the uterus and tubes to fertilize the egg. Should the sperm manage to enter the uterus or the fallopian tubes, this IUD also creates a lining in the uterus that is unfriendly to fertilized eggs.
The copper IUD lasts longer but can cause some women to have heavier, more painful periods, so it may not be the best option for women who already have those issues. "Its not dangerous, but it can be a nuisance," says Dr. Foster-Rosales, "so its important that women are aware of it and willing to deal with it."
Next Page: Great for women who shouldn't get pregnant and those with anemia [ pagebreak ]Great for women who shouldn't get pregnant and those with anemia
Mirena releases a small amount of levonorgostrel locally in the uterus, and the side effects are less severe than those caused by the copper IUD. "Women can tend to spot at first," says Dr. Foster-Rosales, but she adds that the bleeding subsides after several months, and after a year, 20% have no period at all. This makes it a great method for women who have anemia due to heavy periods, as that tends to improve or even resolve with this IUD.
For women who have medical problems that make pregnancy dangerous, "IUDs are often a very, very good choice," says Dr. Foster-Rosales, "because they are highly effective: an unplanned pregnancy would be uncommon, there are relatively few side effects, and they are unlikely to interfere with medications or aggravate any other medical conditions the woman might have." No contraceptive is 100% foolproof, but becoming pregnant while using an IUD is very uncommon.