Others sound less favorable. Uninsured people will have to buy health insurancea policy known as the "individual mandate"or pay a fine. Some of those people will qualify for Medicaid (which will be expanded under the new law), and some may choose to buy into their employers’ health-care plans. Most, however, will have to select a private insurance plan through new, state-run insurance marketplaces (or "exchanges").
The individual mandate won’t go into effect until 2014, but it has already generated controversy. More than a dozen state attorneys general have challenged it as unconstitutional and an encroachment on state sovereignty, and some people have suggested that the fineswhich are as low as $95 in the first yearwon’t persuade people to buy an insurance plan that may be far more expensive.
What will the individual mandate mean for you? Will it actually work?
To find out, we asked Michael Doonan, PhD, an assistant professor at the Heller School for Social Policy and Management at Brandeis University, in Waltham, Mass. The buy-insurance-or-pay policy is closely modeled on the one that took effect in Massachusetts in 2006 as part of the state’s health-care reform. Doonan has studied the individual mandate in his home state extensively, and has suggested that the experience in Massachusetts holds many lessons for the national version.
Q. Why is the requirement to purchase insurance an important feature of health reform?
A: Ending preexisting-condition exclusions and requiring health insurance companies to provide insurance to all takers would be difficult without the mandate. If people knew they could get coverage for an illness at anytime, they might just wait until they were sick to sign up. Having a significant number of people paying premiums only when they’re sick would cause health-care premiums to spike and would be a disaster for the American health-care system.
The mandate will lead to more healthy people being covered, and adding these people to the health insurance "risk pool" will theoretically lower the per-person cost of insurance. Who’s buying individual health insurance polices right now? People who think they’re going to need health insurance. Therefore, costs are really, really high. And so if you say, "Alright, healthy people, you need to jump into that pool," then those costs are going to be lowered.
Former Massachusetts governor Mitt Romney made the argument [for a mandate] based on the concept of individual responsibility. For example, if someone is uninsured but gets into a car accident, they still receive care. And if they can’t pay, the costs are passed along in higher premiums to everyone who is covered.